|
Book Reviews
There are an
amazing number of books available
about the Anasazi. There are books about the
Anasazi themselves ;
who they were, how they lived, and what happened to them. There are
also lots of books about visiting Anasazi country. Many are generic,
focusing on the anasazi sites that are developed and promoted. There
are many amazing sotes throught the Four Corners area and a good guide
book is vital to enjoying your visit.There are also a number of
detailed hiking guides full of valuable
information for anyone interested in exploring the wilder parts of the
area. I have read and own many books on all aspects of the Anasazi and
I can't tell you how much pleasure I have gotten while learning from
them. and am a firm believer that owning some of these books
is
|
Cedar
Mesa Area Hiking Guides
The
Cedar Mesa area of Sooutheastern Utah offers many different
opportunities for hiking to undeveloped Anasazi ruins and rock art. You
can fins all types of visiting experience ranging from a developed site
with paved access to multi day backpacking trips into desert
wilderness. The best way to develop a plan for learning more about this
area is to invest in one of more hiking guides. The following threee
books are ones that I use constantly. Each has its own strengths and
weaknessess which I outline below. If you are interested in visitng
Anasazi ruins in their natural state would will want these guides.
|
Cedar Mesa Hikes SE Utah by Jim
Beard
152 pages, paperback, 8"x5"
Jim Beard has been helping
people discover
Anasazi Country for many years. He publishes the website www.anasazis.com where
he provides a
lot of great information.. He is a very serious hiker and has spent
most of the past 20 plus years exploring the area. This book provides
the most comprehensive guide there is to hiking on Cedar Mesa. He
discusses all of the major and minor access points to all of the
associated canyons. The hike descriptions always provide enough
information for an experienced hiker and give accurate information
about hiking obstacles and routes.
This book is for the
experienced hiker not the
beginner. Beard does not provide specific directions to most ruins. In
fact, he rarely mentions ruins by name and expects his readers to make
their own discovereis. Many of the accesses he discusses are
undeveloped in any way and may be difficult to find and follow for
inexperienced hikers. He does not provide GPS coordinates. Beard has
his own writing style which some find difficult. However, the info is
first rate and accurate.
I love this book and depend on
it for my trip
planning. This book is a must have for anyone serious about hiking on
Cedar Mesa.
|
|
A Hiking Guide to Cedar Mesa by
Peter
Tassoni 195 pages, paperback, 9"x6"
This was the first guide book
I ever had to
hiking in Anasazi country. It features Comb Ridge hikes as well as
covering all of Cedar Mesa and the associated canyons. This book is not
as comprehensive as the Beard guide described above but it is better
suited to those new to hiking in the area. Tassoni provides place names
and directions for finding many of the most spectacular ruins in the
area. He gives a lot of specific data, including GPS coordinated for
many car parks, trail heads and archeology sites. Be aware that there
are some GPS errors in the book and many of his hike descriptions are a
little off. However, in total the book does a good job of getting you
to the best known sites in the area.
The content layout in the book
is a little
cumbersome with all of the GPS coordinates listed in a table instead of
in the associated text. This means you have to flip pages a lot but I
considr this a minor annoyance.
In summary, I think this is the best
book for the
first time visitor to Cedar Mesa. It covers all of the major trails and
sites and givs good basic information for all hikers.
|
|
Canyon Hiking Guide to the
Colorado
Plateau: Non-Technical by Michael Kelsey 384
pages,
paperback, 9"x6"
This book is both much more
and much less than
the two books above. It is a guide to almost every canyon of the
Colorado River drainage. It includes descriptions of hikes in 120
canyons in Utah, Colorado and Arizona. While some canyons have just a
single hike associated with them, many have multiple hikes in a single
canyon so the total number of hikes/trailheads covered is much higher.
This book was not written for
beginning hikers
but gives beginners amuch of the information they need. Kelsey includes
maps and geologic cross sections for each canyon described. The author
has a very concentrated writing style and he gets a lot of detailed
hiking information into each page. This is a very dense book using a
small type font and very little white space on the page. This can make
it hard to read at times but only because you are getting so many
details.
Kelsey primarily
uses the metric system
for reporting distances in the book. For major distances he usually
includes miles as well but most distances are given as metric only.
Kelsey provides a conversion chart but it is cumbersum if you have to
consult a chart for every distance. Another factor to be aware of is
that Kelsey is an amazingly strong hiker and his personal hiking times
should never be used as a guide. He attempts to provides hiking times
for what he considers an average hiker but I have found that most
actual hikers need longer (even much longer) times than his
suggestions.
This book is a hiking guide
and not an Anasazi
guide so it discusses quite a few canyons with no archeological sites.
Where ruins exist, Kelsey points out a lot of them. His maps show where
to look for ruins and rock art and his hiking descriptions often talk
of ruins by name.
In summary, this book provides
detailed
information about almost every canyon in the region. Accurate
information along with maps and photos are strong points. However, the
information in this book is less accessible than the others and it may
take you some time to get comfortable with Kelsey's style. For an
experienced hiker this is the best choice.
|
|
Grand Gulch, UT -
National Geographic
Trails Illustrated Map Approximately 4" x 9"
folded, 26" x
38" opened, Scale = 1:62,500
I am a big beleiver in the
value of having and
using good maps and this is the best map available for the Cedar Mesa
area. It covers all of Grand Gulch and most of the associated areas.
Map coverage extends as far East as Butler Wash, so, most Comb Ridge
hikes are on this map. It strikes a good balance beteween size, scale
and detail and is a valuable tool for hikers. If you are exploring the
areas North of the map boundry you will need the Manti
La Sal National Forest, Utah
map in addition to the Grans Gulch map.
Learning to understand and
properly use maps
is one of the most important aspects of hiking in backcountry areas.
Many canyon hikes are in places where there are no developed trails and
it is vital that you learn to use your maps. This map is a must have.
|
|
Regional
Anasazi Guide Books
|
Ancient Ruins of the
Southwest: An Archaeological Guide (Arizona and the Southwest) by David
Grant Noble 160 pages, paperback,
9"x6" 2000
|
|
|
Anasazi Ruins
of the Southwest by William M. Ferguson and Arthur H. Rohn 310
pages, paperback, 11"x8.5"
1987 |
|
Books
About the Anasazi
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Comb Ridge Books
|
Comb Ridge and Its People: The Ethnohistory of a Rock by Robert McPherson 264 pages, paperback, 8 1/2" x 11"
|
|
Sandstone Spine: Seeking the
Anasazi on the First Traverse of the Comb Ridge by
David Roberts, photos by Greg Child 190 pages, hardbound,
6" x 9"
This is the story of an epic
backpacking trip and Anasazi exploration. Beginning the hike where Comb
Ridge first begins to emerge from the ground in Arizona, the trip takes
three friends northward all the way to the end of the ridge. Most of
this trip takes place in wildneress on the Navajo Rservation and the
logistics of the hike are very complex. Read my full review of Sandstone Spine
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Copyright
This website and
all contents and
design, including images, are protected under U.S. Copyright ©
2011 by Anasazihikes.com. All rights reserved worldwide.
anasazi.com is for your personal and noncommercial use. No one may
modify, copy, distribute, transmit, display, or publish any materials
contained in anasazihikes.com without prior written permission. anasazihikes.com is a registered service mark and may not be used without
permission.
|